What proof is there that Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, or Albert Einstein had or have Asperger's? This question is based on the statements of Fred Landis in two questions about the biography of Steve Jobs. Do many people believe this? Why?

Updated on : January 20, 2022 by Kareem Best



What proof is there that Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, or Albert Einstein had or have Asperger's? This question is based on the statements of Fred Landis in two questions about the biography of Steve Jobs. Do many people believe this? Why?

  • The question is misleading in that it alleges that the core of my dissatisfaction with the Jobs biography is my belief that Jobs has Asperger's. I never said such a thing. I just make the obvious point that with the current interest in Asperger and the widespread belief that Asperger is common in Silicon Valley, any current biography of Jobs or Gates should address the issue frankly and openly rather than as a dark secret. .
  • The claim that the interrogator has never heard of such a thing is nonsense, as Google is full of it. When I had a Mac, the first 20 books I got
Keep reading
  • The question is misleading in that it alleges that the core of my dissatisfaction with the Jobs biography is my belief that Jobs has Asperger's. I never said such a thing. I just make the obvious point that with the current interest in Asperger and the widespread belief that Asperger is common in Silicon Valley, any current biography of Jobs or Gates should address the issue frankly and openly rather than as a dark secret. .
  • The claim that the interrogator has never heard of such a thing is nonsense, as Google is full of it. When I had a Mac, the first 20 books I bought on computers included tirades against Bill Gates. In this context, speculating that a person rocking back and forth while speaking might have Asperger's would be the least controversial. The problem is Isaacson's denial, not Landis's claim.
  • In a book review there is no reasonable claim or expectation that the person is making a clinical diagnosis. The charge of having the person alive on a couch would mean that biographers could not apply modern science to our understanding of historical figures.
  • Before Jobs's book was published, I predicted that Isaacson would make the same mistake as Einstein's book, explicitly denying that Aspergers was relevant to the discussion, because he was raised on Bettelheim's idea that autism had no basis. genetics and was caused by frigid mothers.
  • By the currently agreed criteria for Asperger, most people would say that Gates is a likely and should at least provide a respectful discussion on the subject in any current biography of Einstein or Steve Jobs. A good example would be the current biography of PAM Dirac, which dedicates a whole chapter to Asperger.
  • The official field of autism as practiced in America gave us Bettelheim, Freudian explanations, facilitated communication, vaccination as a cause, and diet as a possible cure. In these circumstances, any informed person who has read some recent books on the subject is just as well informed as the so-called experts.
  • Michael Fitzgerald, author of 5 books on Aspergers, dedicated an entire chapter in one to Albert Einstein. He mentions that he had a big head, slow child development, great trouble playing with other children, lonely, and a visual thinker. (Genius Genes, How Asperger's Talents Changed the World). The dust jacket identifies the author as a professor of adolescent psychiatry in Ireland: his special interest is Asperger's syndrome and he has clinically diagnosed more than 1,500 people with autism or Asperger's. Unlike Americans, he constantly quotes Hans Asperger.

Steve Jobs Asperger's proof can be found in the crazy MAC OS organization. Their way of thinking is reflected in the fact that their designs are wildly innovative and creative, but when it comes to logic, the MAC challenges the clean and clear - and sometimes boring - structure that can be found on the Microsoft platform. It's interesting to me how so many visually oriented people who never really learned to type properly swear by the MAC and love its cool looks and point-and-click way of working. But if they primarily used computers to create and store tens of thousands of te

Keep reading

Steve Jobs Asperger's proof can be found in the crazy MAC OS organization. Their way of thinking is reflected in the fact that their designs are wildly innovative and creative, but when it comes to logic, the MAC challenges the clean and clear - and sometimes boring - structure that can be found on the Microsoft platform. It's interesting to me how so many visually oriented people who never really learned to type properly swear by the MAC and love its cool looks and point-and-click way of working. But if you were primarily using computers to create and store tens of thousands of text-based files, like me, and you preferred keyboard shortcuts to drop-down menus, you wouldn't like the MAC so much.

The file trees, the way the "finder" is organized, the names of the various processes and folders on the system, all of this is completely maddening, especially if you are unlucky enough to "inherit" a MAC that has been used by others (as I currently do for one of my jobs). On a PC, it's not that difficult to pick up where someone else left off and search for files, largely because a PC almost forces you to save documents in the right place, while it's very easy for things to get incorrectly filed on a MAC. (I don't have time to get into that here). This is probably why the MAC has a much superior "search" function, on the other hand, which is much faster than on a PC. But on the other hand, I prefer to go find my files where they belong, rather than having to remember their names to be able to search them. By my deduction process, Gates definitely did not suffer from Asperger's. Your operating system is too logical and makes sense to more people.

It is not possible to make an official diagnosis of a medical condition unless you are a treating physician ... this question is a bit like the click bait articles, "What stars have had plastic surgery?" showing before and after images, sometimes 30 years apart ... Doctors can speculate whether changes in an aging face are due to gravity, the sun and fine lines or cosmetic surgery, but unless Let them be the treating doctor, everything is speculation.

My husband is on the spectrum. My son has autism. My husband is a brilliant salesman, the best I have ever seen. Have you learned enough about

Keep reading

It is not possible to make an official diagnosis of a medical condition unless you are a treating physician ... this question is a bit like the click bait articles, "What stars have had plastic surgery?" showing before and after images, sometimes 30 years apart ... Doctors can speculate whether changes in an aging face are due to gravity, the sun and fine lines or cosmetic surgery, but unless Let them be the treating doctor, everything is speculation.

My husband is on the spectrum. My son has autism. My husband is a brilliant salesman, the best I have ever seen. He has learned enough about how to manipulate people to convince the majority to do just about anything he wants them to do ... but he doesn't understand people at all. Hang up the phone in the middle of the conversation, never saying goodbye. When I get home from a two-month trip, he doesn't greet me with a hug and says he's glad to see me. His idea of ​​a date night is to take his best friend out to dinner and a movie. The only way I could convince him NOT to cut his nails in bed was to undress the bed and change the sheets every time I broke my "no nails in bed" rule ...

"Why can't I cut my toenails in bed? You don't think my toenails are gross when they're on my feet. One second are they okay, the next second are they disgusting? That makes no sense."

“You can cut your toenails in bed if you want. But if you do, we'll change the sheets before I sleep in bed. "

"Oh. Okay," she murmurs as she goes to the bathroom to cut her toenails. In this case, you don't need to UNDERSTAND why. You just need to know that there is a consequence (changing the sheets) if you do.

You don't want to hurt anyone's feelings. He cares A LOT about how people feel and what they think of him. But he absolutely CANNOT SAY what people think or feel. You can convince them of anything, but you cannot tell what they are thinking or feeling. It's the most cursed thing ...

But back to the question ... the answer depends on what you mean by "proof". There is certainly a lot of anecdotal evidence that these people were on the spectrum. I have read and heard stories of things that I could fully and totally imagine my husband doing ... or seeing my husband do, even though he has the warmest heart out there.

Those anecdotes are enough to give credence to the idea that these men were most likely somewhere on the spectrum. . . particularly with the diagnosis of psychologists who have applied current knowledge of the autism spectrum to the anecdotal behaviors of these men and have obtained a positive diagnosis.

But that may not be enough "proof" for you ... and without these doctors looking into the matter, any "diagnosis" they provide is speculation.

None.

Asperger syndrome must be diagnosed by evaluation. Someone could only speculate which celebrity might have Asperger's Syndrome, or anything else, based on short television interviews or even a biography.

I have read the biography of Steve Jobs, and sometimes he acts cruel, and he has a great interest in design, but that does not mean that he has Asperger syndrome. Asperger syndrome can mean not picking up on social cues, and that can sometimes be interpreted as rude. Asperger syndrome also consists of an intense interest in a particular topic. However it is

Keep reading

None.

Asperger syndrome must be diagnosed by evaluation. Someone could only speculate which celebrity might have Asperger's Syndrome, or anything else, based on short television interviews or even a biography.

I have read the biography of Steve Jobs, and sometimes he acts cruel, and he has a great interest in design, but that does not mean that he has Asperger syndrome. Asperger syndrome can mean not picking up on social cues, and that can sometimes be interpreted as rude. Asperger syndrome also consists of an intense interest in a particular topic. However, it is those two possible things along with a host of other areas that have to meet certain criteria for someone to be diagnosed with Asperger syndrome. For example, people with Asperger syndrome sometimes don't process prosody. I would say that Steve Jobs had to know how to read people, understand their inflections and social signals, to be able to negotiate and manipulate people as well as he.

The most interesting thing this question raises is how personality and different parts of the brain are so closely intertwined with experience to make someone who they are. There are a number of possible gene / personality / environment combinations in which someone may have very strong characteristics related to Asperger's syndrome, but do not have them in a severe enough way or do not meet sufficient criteria to be diagnosed.

It would be very difficult to diagnose someone after reading a book about him, watching an interview, or hearing second-hand reports about him.

Einstein was a genius above all else, so putting Gates and Jobs in the same category is ridiculous. He got along well with others and seemed relatively well adjusted to me. He should have been able to get along well enough with others within the scientific community for his ideas to be heard. Concern about humanity not getting involved with the atomic bomb indicates less selfish than the average NT. His own category of genius, I'd say.

Gates is not liked by many, but he has a philanthropic stance, so these are clues that he might be closer to ASD (similar to Greta Thurnberg), but Jobs was a

Keep reading

Einstein was a genius above all else, so putting Gates and Jobs in the same category is ridiculous. He got along well with others and seemed relatively well adjusted to me. He should have been able to get along well enough with others within the scientific community for his ideas to be heard. Concern about humanity not getting involved with the atomic bomb indicates less selfish than the average NT. His own category of genius, I'd say.

Gates is not liked by many, but he has a philanthropic stance, so these are clues that he might be closer to ASD (similar to Greta Thurnberg), but Jobs was an opportunist who could use others to his advantage. , so it emits much more than NT. vibe for me. If I were neurodiverse, I would go more with ADHD than with ASD.

Macs are all about form over function, which is exactly what NTs are all about. Windows PCs are the complete opposite.

Steve Jobs, I am sure he is an Asperger, as it is possible to be a great leader of people and still have Aspergers Syndrome. I've seen Winston Churchill, Abraham Lincoln, and Al Gore on the Asperger Syndrome list.
It's a pure Asperger's focus on something that makes them successful. People who have that kind of determination and focus become extremely interesting to other people if they are innovative and different, regardless of how quirky or different they are.
An Asperger diagnosis in a way comes down to probability. No two Aspergers are alike, not even if you have more than one in

Keep reading

Steve Jobs, I am sure he is an Asperger, as it is possible to be a great leader of people and still have Aspergers Syndrome. I've seen Winston Churchill, Abraham Lincoln, and Al Gore on the Asperger Syndrome list.
It's a pure Asperger's focus on something that makes them successful. People who have that kind of determination and focus become extremely interesting to other people if they are innovative and different, regardless of how quirky or different they are.
An Asperger diagnosis in a way comes down to probability. No two Aspergers are alike, not even if you have more than one in the same family. Because there is a long list of criteria that you can meet to be an Asperger, but you only have to meet a certain number of criteria, this means that people with Asperger's can differ a lot, but they may share some common traits that vary between different Aspergers. .

This is a good question. Right now, we are in the process of identifying aspects of neurodiversity that are evident throughout written history. Leonardo da Vinci's diaries are just one example, diaries that were used to make a movie of his life.

Essentially, when you look at the attributes of those of us with autism and study other people now alive, or well known in our written records, it becomes relatively easy to see characteristics that, if those people were to land in a psychiatrist (or other professional diagnostic office) experienced), they are likely to date at least one of the

Keep reading

This is a good question. Right now, we are in the process of identifying aspects of neurodiversity that are evident throughout written history. Leonardo da Vinci's diaries are just one example, diaries that were used to make a movie of his life.

Essentially, when you look at the attributes of those of us with autism, and study other people now alive, or well known in our written archives, it becomes relatively easy to see characteristics that, if those people were to land in a psychiatrist (or other diagnostic office) seasoned professional, they would probably come up with at least one of the autism spectrum diagnoses.

That's as simple as I can make it without explaining to you how different autistic people are from non-autistic people, but hopefully that helps.

Some people with Asperger's like to use any reference to traits that fall within the diagnostic criteria to infer that various famous people are or were autistic. This is often used as evidence that Aspergers confer superior abilities and / or that Aspies are superior to mere neurotypicals.

However, the traits in question are generally characteristics that occur on a spectrum ranging from neurotypicity to full-blown autism, or are typical of introverts in general. Not that the criteria are clearly inhuman signs, such as breathing fire or having a pearly horn in the center of the forehead. U.S'

Keep reading

Some people with Asperger's like to use any reference to traits that fall within the diagnostic criteria to infer that various famous people are or were autistic. This is often used as evidence that Aspergers confer superior abilities and / or that Aspies are superior to mere neurotypicals.

However, the traits in question are generally characteristics that occur on a spectrum ranging from neurotypicity to full-blown autism, or are typical of introverts in general. Not that the criteria are clearly inhuman signs, such as breathing fire or having a pearly horn in the center of the forehead. We are talking about things like being reserved, studious, socially awkward, analytical, restless, etc.

I hope this helps!

No proof at all. None were deteriorated enough to qualify as such. Albert Einstein had a speech delay and didn't have many friends at school, but it was probably because he had learning disabilities in reading and memorizing facts. Bill Gates does not have AS as he is a successful businessman. Ditto for Steve Jobs, he was pretty smart and made tough business decisions that someone with AS couldn't make.

I have Asperger syndrome. I was diagnosed with it. You cannot tell from a book or an interview whether a person has it or not. In the case of Steve Jobs, that man was very insensitive and calculating, I seriously doubt it. To me he was more of a psycho than an Aspie, and when I say psycho, I mean the ones that work, not the killers. They are out there. Asps are not usually insensitive or calculating.

You have to be careful here. There is a similarity between being an Aspie and being a Nerd. It is very rare to be able to abstract from a person's biography how many of Aspberger's stigmata that person had. However, there is one case in which there is practically no doubt; PAM Dirac. I couldn't get a more textbook set of symptoms.

Other Guides:


GET SPECIAL OFFER FROM OUR PARTNER.