For civil engineering, is it better to have a government job or a private job?

Updated on : January 17, 2022 by Madeleine Thompson



For civil engineering, is it better to have a government job or a private job?

If by "best" you mean the "most interesting type of projects", it is a personal preference based on the type of jobs you enjoy working on and the pace you are looking for. Private development generally has the budget for more exclusive projects with creative elements, but is often extremely fast-paced and demanding. Government development generally has strict standards and specifications that you must use (not a lot of creative flexibility), but it may be a more desirable pace to hit milestones.

If by "better" you mean "greater job security", that also varies. Private development is much more sens

Keep reading

If by "best" you mean the "most interesting type of projects", it is a personal preference based on the type of jobs you enjoy working on and the pace you are looking for. Private development generally has the budget for more exclusive projects with creative elements, but is often extremely fast-paced and demanding. Government development generally has strict standards and specifications that you must use (not a lot of creative flexibility), but it may be a more desirable pace to hit milestones.

If by "better" you mean "greater job security", that also varies. Private development is much more sensitive to the state of the economy, however it can also close the gap for economic downturns if developers know there will still be demand afterward. Government development is also affected by the state of the economy, but money will generally be continually pumped in to power the industry, and especially in the US, a LOT of infrastructure improvements are needed.

If you mean what “type of company” to work for, private or government, that also depends on your personal preferences. In a private company, you may see more career growth opportunities, salary increases, and sometimes benefits. Also take a look at the projects the company is pursuing; it is generally best to diversify both public and private development so that they are ready for either industry to take a hit. A government job will have a good PTO, strict 40 hour weeks (in private industry you can work 40+ hours), and generally have more job security, but you may not see as many opportunities for career growth or salary increases, since all are usually standardized. .

I hope this helps!

Well, there is no point waiting for the government. Jobs, as there are many private jobs available for graduates. You can also enter the private sector to earn good money and build a great career.

However, in case you have an option where you have a change to enter the government. Sector, I would like to list the best reasons why you should go to the Government. Sector.

For most middle-class Indians, there has been a perpetual dilemma: looking for a job in the private sector or in the government sector. In the last two decades, jobs in the private sector became fashionable, before which government work

Keep reading

Well, there is no point waiting for the government. Jobs, as there are many private jobs available for graduates. You can also enter the private sector to earn good money and build a great career.

However, in case you have an option where you have a change to enter the government. Sector, I would like to list the best reasons why you should go to the Government. Sector.

For most middle-class Indians, there has been a perpetual dilemma: looking for a job in the private sector or in the government sector. In the past two decades, private sector jobs came into vogue, before which government work was the ultimate prize for job seekers.

We seem to be back in the days when government jobs are starting to get attractive again. This article looks at the advantages of government jobs over private sector jobs.


Advantages of government sector jobs over the private sector:

  • Job security

The biggest advantage of government work is "job security."

The private sectors are prone to layoffs and we have witnessed such layoffs in the past during recession times. Whereas, in government sectors, the situation of employees more or less remained the same and jobs remained intact.

  • Payment structure

Now the next significant factor would be the salary structure as it is a very important factor for any individual looking for employment. After the introduction of the sixth pay commission, the salary a government employee receives is on par with the corporate sector and I don't think you have anything to complain about here.

  • Working hours

Personally, I think the next factor an employee would scratch their head for is the amount of work hours they have to put in and that's a huge advantage over the private sector. In government sector jobs, there are standard work schedules, unlike in the private sector, in which a person has to work overtime against their wishes (many times without any benefit as well). And if any situation requires a government employee to work overtime, then you are entitled to attractive overtime benefits.

  • Promotions

One important factor, which any job seeker should consider, is promotional benefits. In government jobs, promotion is always based on term of service, therefore the longer you work and the greater the opportunities for promotion. Obviously, this can be called both an advantage and a disadvantage because, for someone who is above average, they may not be able to grow faster than their average counterparts.

  • Benefits and advantages

Then comes the benefit and perks that a government employee gets. For government jobs, there are many benefits like retirement benefits, pension plans and funds, in addition to benefits like medical, housing, loans, childcare, etc. are also available. While some large private sector companies offer such benefits, most of them do not, except for the required ones.

Retirement becomes a factor and the later part of our career and the retirement age of 60 years and in some cases of 58 years ensures the longevity of an individual's career.

  • Work stress

Government sector jobs are not at all stressful compared to private sector jobs. The workload in government jobs, even if it is high, would have a more than enough time frame to complete it in the best possible way, unlike that of private sector jobs.

And here are some extras too.

- More facilities: Government jobs offer more facilities, such as Internet, phone subscription, LTC. While the quality of the services is debatable, it is nonetheless an advantage.

- Unavoidable salary increase: In government jobs, your salary will increase, which will have no correlation with your performance. While it's great if you work hard, the increases happen if you don't. So for the achievers it can actually be a disadvantage, but if you are average performer this is great.

- More Holidays: There are more government holidays in government jobs compared to the private sector. Plus you also have a 5 day work week. To add to all of this, you also have a certain amount of paid vacation in a year.

- Respect: If you are a government employee, you will gain the respect of a subset of government employees and individuals because of your position and power.

To conclude, the main benefits of working with government organizations is the reputation associated with it in general, as well as the many opportunities that have emerged in recent times due to the stellar growth of the Indian economy.

I only have a bachelor's degree, which is also from a second level private university in South India. Now I work for an EPC giant in the private sector. So I can tell you with certainty that, as exciting as it may sound, working for a private company will have its own downsides. The most important are heavy pressure, awkward working hours, and in most cases a position in a remote area. Your growth possibilities will depend on the type of company you work for.

If it's something like L&T or SPCL, which are mostly in the construction phase, you might end up working on the site and taking care of the execution.

Keep reading

I only have a bachelor's degree, which is also from a second level private university in South India. Now I work for an EPC giant in the private sector. So I can tell you with certainty that, as exciting as it may sound, working for a private company will have its own downsides. The most important are heavy pressure, awkward working hours, and in most cases a position in a remote area. Your growth possibilities will depend on the type of company you work for.

If it's something like L&T or SPCL, which are mostly in the construction phase, you might end up working on site and taking care of the execution work. And frankly, very little engineering goes into the site. It's pretty much a job for your management skills and general common sense. Another warning: if you have a bachelor's degree, it's not exactly enough to land a design-based job. Most companies prefer postgraduates. However, if you manage to find work in a consulting firm, you will have a clerical job and little exposure to the kinds of problems you face during execution.

Therefore, even if you enter the private sector, be sure of what you want to do and enter a suitable company accordingly. But again, you can always make the best use of situations and shape yourself. It really depends on how you want to look at it.

I answered a similar question elsewhere. Give it a read if you can :)

Teja Jupudi's answer to Is it really bad that you can't break a government job and work in the private sector?

I would prefer to go private for the following reasons. Note "The grass is always greener on the other side"

More exposure to learn.

Opportunity to work in Metro Cities.

However, the option to change the location is not possible in the government, as you must work in one location and within the state if you work at the state level job for your entire life.

Option to go abroad while, in the case of the government, only the government can decide whether to go or not.

Easy procedure to get out of the private, however, in the Government, the same time is required.

No entry required and a

Keep reading

I would prefer to go private for the following reasons. Note "The grass is always greener on the other side"

More exposure to learn.

Opportunity to work in Metro Cities.

However, the option to change the location is not possible in the government, as you must work in one location and within the state if you work at the state level job for your entire life.

Option to go abroad while, in the case of the government, only the government can decide whether to go or not.

Easy procedure to get out of the private, however, in the Government, the same time is required.

No entry is required and an interview is sufficient to join in private; however, you must prepare to compete with many applicants who write for government.

The starting salary can be the same, however the private employee will get more based on performance and experience (speaking of the salary employees get through the bank).

More active than the fear of dismissal, however, the same does not happen in the Government.

Most of the work in government is done by a private contractor, so the government employee only sees the paperwork.

Safer in government, however, privatization can eliminate this.

Some of the rights may be waived by the government before joining, however it would not be the same in private.

Long procedure to join even after the exam is finished, so applicants have to wait until they join, however, it is not the same in private, as if there is a delay from private and then the employee also gives interviews / looks at another company.

Society prefers to go to government more; however, the same is true in the north and not in the south, as an educated family knows the importance of time and work in places other than government.

All the best.

It largely depends on the person. There is no single answer to this question.

If you are enthusiastic about engineering, want to excel professionally (which may or may not mean financial success), and your job motivates you, I'd say a private job is for you. The reason I say this is because private organizations value core performance much more than government organizations, and the amount of work you do is much more directly related to the rewards you get. In most private companies, performance is promoted as it directly increases their income.

If, on the contrary, your interests are somewhere

Keep reading

It largely depends on the person. There is no single answer to this question.

If you are enthusiastic about engineering, want to excel professionally (which may or may not mean financial success), and your job motivates you, I'd say a private job is for you. The reason I say this is because private organizations value core performance much more than government organizations, and the amount of work you do is much more directly related to the rewards you get. In most private companies, performance is promoted as it directly increases their income.

If, on the other hand, your interests lie elsewhere, you want things like job security, a constant and predictable source of income, maybe the "better" things in life, like food, movies, reading, etc. ., they excite you more than the design of a building. So I think a government job might be a better option for you. It would provide you with the time and stability to pursue any other interests you have (which may not be financially viable to pursue full time). In my opinion, government organizations that are not directly driven by revenue makes them lax and inefficient, but it has its own advantages for many people.

That being said, some government organizations are of course doing a great job, ISRO in India for example. A well-informed choice must be made, what I or anyone else tells you here can only give you a very general idea that may or may not be relevant to you personally.

Regarding your questions, you will find various types of views from various people. The debate over who has a better life, that is, a private employee or a government employee, will never end. You may notice that both sides of people would prefer to stay on their own side because it is their comfort zone. It depends on your ambitions, goal, goal of how you want your life to be. If you want a stable life with ease, without challenges, relaxation, then definitely look for a government job. The government job has its own imp, its pay scale would be smaller but it would receive various incentives, various allowances, rents and all. Also, buy

Keep reading

Regarding your questions, you will find various types of views from various people. The debate over who has a better life, that is, a private employee or a government employee, will never end. You may notice that both sides of people would prefer to stay on their own side because it is their comfort zone. It depends on your ambitions, goal, goal of how you want your life to be. If you want a stable life with ease, without challenges, relaxation, then definitely look for a government job. The government job has its own imp, its pay scale would be smaller but it would receive various incentives, various allowances, rents and all. Furthermore, compared to the private sector, the level of tension and stress is low. Now, if your goal is to grow and enjoy the challenges that come your way, If you want your life to become a roller coaster ride, then opt for a private job. It will offer you day-to-day challenges, learning experience, The growth rate would be high, but remember that the risk of your work will always be there. While in government work you will have an assured life for a lifetime. Both have their own importance, so think wisely and decide accordingly. According to me, if I were in your place, I would have chosen the difficult path and opted for a Private firm. Best of luck. While in government work you will have an assured life for a lifetime. Both have their own importance, so think wisely and decide accordingly. According to me, if I were in your place, I would have chosen the difficult path and opted for a Private firm. Best of luck. While in government work you will have an assured life for a lifetime. Both have their own importance, so think wisely and decide accordingly. According to me, if I were in your place, I would have chosen the difficult path and opted for a Private firm. Best of luck.

Talking about what I have seen at the beginning in private is better. You will learn more and gain experience in a wider variety in front of the government, where things are more compartmentalized. Often times, the design is primarily done by a consulting design firm, so if you want a real design experience, you won't be on the government's side. On the other hand, later, at the higher levels of government, one can play a role on a much larger scale and the impact can be incredible.

Some people compare benefits, pensions and salaries and that matters, but for me it is a secondary consideration for growth in the profession.

For any graduate, whether to opt for a government job or a private job is left to the passion of the individual. Many people are running behind government jobs, mainly for the following reasons:

1 Fixed working hours,

2 Regular annual salary increase,

3 Occupational safety,

4 Less work stress,

5 More facilities,

6 More holidays,

7 Salary structure,

8 Benefits and other benefits,

9 Promotional benefits,

10 Respect and power.

NOTE:

i) However, it is important to remember that private sector jobs also have their own advantages,

ii) In many cases, a government job may not be suitable for an individual.

Source

Keep reading

For any graduate, whether to opt for a government job or a private job is left to the passion of the individual. Many people are running behind government jobs, mainly for the following reasons:

1 Fixed working hours,

2 Regular annual salary increase,

3 Occupational safety,

4 Less work stress,

5 More facilities,

6 More holidays,

7 Salary structure,

8 Benefits and other benefits,

9 Promotional benefits,

10 Respect and power.

NOTE:

i) However, it is important to remember that private sector jobs also have their own advantages,

ii) In many cases, a government job may not be suitable for an individual.

Image source: Google Images.

Financially.

There are no special advantages in the government sector after 2004, as the pension plan was revised. Payment in the government sector does not increase according to the performance of the individual, while payment in the private sector increases according to the performance of the individual.

Peaceful life.

There is no peace in the government sector as most people think. It is too much workload and political incursion in the government sector.

Conclusion.

The government sector is best for average and below-average students, while the private sector is best for gifted students.

Thank you for reading .

After 10 years as a freelancer in Greece, I have very consciously chosen to work for the private sector. I ended up with a master's and a doctorate that I have paid for entirely on my own, 25 seminars, a few publications, and I still want to grow even though my income has fallen terribly. Due to my qualifications, I can easily be appointed in the public sector, however, I am trying to find a company abroad and collaborate. I do not regret my choices.

If you are service-oriented with the goal of public service as a driving force, but satisfied with a reasonable standard of living, you may prefer a job in government. But if you can work very hard and intend to earn a lot of money for a luxurious life, you are better off looking for a private job.

Other Guides:


GET SPECIAL OFFER FROM OUR PARTNER.